9 July 2018 | Public Administration & the Border Crisis, by Manny Teodoro*

Kevin, · Categories: monthly_posts

Public Administration Professionalism at the Flashpoint

Presidents issue orders, Congress passes laws, and courts make judgments, but immigration policy really succeeds or fails when bureaucrats interact with people seeking entry to the United States. Immigration policy is what happens when an ICE agent detains an individual (or doesn’t), separates children from parents (or doesn’t), and puts kids in cages (or doesn’t). Immigration policy is what happens when a DHS contractor attends to a wailing toddler, or leaves frightened children to their own devices in adherence to administrative guidelines. In the end, human rights are protected or violated not by politicians, but by the men and women who put regulations into action.

What drives bureaucratic behavior?

Although public attention tends to fixate on laws and rules when trying to understand public policy, decades of public administration research indicates that organizational norms and values determine what public servants do. Public employees from soldiers to teachers to police officers look to their peers for informal guidance on what is honorable, acceptable, or forbidden. Monitoring systems and the threat of disciplinary action turn out to be lousy predictors of public administrators’ actions. When bureaucrats enforce (or refuse to enforce) rules, it’s because their fellow bureaucrats sanction that behavior. Smart public agency leaders do not rely solely on orders, but rather seek to instill systems of ethics and build a sense of mission in their organizations.

Professionalization in public administration is an effort to enhance this kind of peer accountability by building loyalty to principles of public service. America’s military academies are excellent examples: they seek to build within officers not only respect for chain-of-command, but also a system of ethics that defines military professionalism. In the ideal, professions provide an “inner-check,” enforced by social approbation or disdain by fellow professionals, that guides individuals to uphold shared norms and resist unethical orders.

Administration at the border

The agencies at the flashpoint of America’s current immigration crisis give plenty of reason to worry. The main bureau charged with implementation of immigration laws is the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agency, which was formed fifteen years ago when the US Customs Service (part of the Treasury Department) and Immigration and Naturalization Service (Justice Department) were consolidated within the new Department of Homeland Security as part of the post-9/11 reforms. Organizational culture and professionalization take time to develop, but this young agency has been charged with implementing some of the country’s most vexing and incendiary policies, even as its nascent culture is still forming. In early 2017 the Trump Administration ordered the hiring of 10,000 new ICE agents. Simply hiring and training that many people quickly is a daunting task; professionalizing and building a sense of mission in each new agent even more so. The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) provides a useful contrast. ICE and FBI agents each receive 20 weeks of training upon entry into their agencies. But new FBI agents must also be accomplished college graduates, and upon appointment they enter a highly-professionalized agency with thousands of experienced agents, a storied history, and deep sense of organizational identity. It is not surprising that FBI officials have been more defiant, and ICE officials more acquiescent, in their relationships with the Trump White House.

DHS also relies heavily on private contractors to operate detention facilities, and some of the most troubling accounts of child migrant treatment emerge from these privately-operated facilities. If public administration professionalism implies loyalty to professional norms and ethics, then private contracting does just the opposite. A contractor’s livelihood depends upon satisfying a client (in this case, DHS executives), adhering to regulations, and fulfilling contracts. A contractor whose personnel refuse to treat migrant children as specified in a contract is likely to find that contract terminated.

Administrative evil and public professionalism

Governments can do great good and evil because bureaucratic agencies provide the capacity to put policy into action, as Guy Adams has observed. Administrative evil is not a consequence of inefficiency (the usual bureaucratic lament), but rather a result of a technical rationality that is the very hallmark of bureaucracy. Without professionalism, bureaucrats pass accountability for their actions to political superiors. Indeed, a naïve view of democratic accountability would demand dutiful compliance by ICE agents to orders (or tweets?) issued from above. Public service professionalism implies that a federal employee’s primary duty is to the public good, not to the whims of the person at the top of the organizational chart. Without a foundation of professional ethics and systems of accountability to professional peers, the rational administrator can find himself or herself participating in destructive acts.

So long as the United States has borders, it will need an agency to make those borders meaningful. But building a sense of professionalism and peer-accountability to ethical principles is crucial to ICE’s or any other border enforcement agency’s role in a democratic state. In 1952, political scientist Norton Long reflected on the lessons of the Second World War for American public administration:

It is a fortunate fact of our working constitution that it is complemented by a bureaucracy indoctrinated with the fundamental ideals of constitutionalism… In a real and important sense, it provides a constitutional check on both legislature and executive. It is no neutral instrument like the German bureaucracy, available to Nazi and democrat alike, pleading its orders from ‘die hohe Tiere’ as an excuse for criminal acts.

The decency of the agents charged with implementing public policy is a crucial check against government abuse. Professional public servants are the first line of defense and the last best hope for protecting human dignity in times of political turmoil.

 

*Originally published June 22, 2018 at http://mannyteodoro.com/?p=427.

42 Responses to “9 July 2018 | Public Administration & the Border Crisis, by Manny Teodoro*”

  1. Extended Opportunity says:

    He Got 256,354 Free Views With AI…

    Can you believe it?

    People spend thousands of dollars to get that kind of result…

    My friend Kundan just did it for free…

    He only used his new app… AI ScreenSnap…

    It’s the world’s first AI app that can generate videos with the power of Video-Exclusive AI Engine…

    That can edit, record, and generate videos with just a few clicks… with zero experience…

    Click here now and watch AI ScreenSnap in action https://ext-opp.com/AIScreenSnap

  2. mohidkh says:

    Ace the Cramkey HPE7-A01 exam with Cramkey’s thorough study resources. Access concise notes, practice questions, and tailored materials for effective preparation. Ensure success in your certification journey with their comprehensive exam readiness tools.

  3. This website is unbelievable. The radiant material shows the creator’s enthusiasm. I’m dumbfounded and envision more such astonishing entries.

  4. Extended Opportunity says:

    Hey,

    The moment we’ve all been waiting for is finally here – GoBuildr is now LIVE!

    Create ultra-lightning-fast websites, sales funnels, eCommerce stores, and more in less than 60 seconds, with just a keyword!

    Say goodbye to the limitations of traditional page builders. GoBuildr combines the functionality of 16 different tools into one powerful app, supercharged with AI-assisted technology.

    ⇒ Click Here To Checkout Demo https://ext-opp.com/GoBuildr

  5. Moses2854 says:

    The Beatles – легендарная британская рок-группа, сформированная в 1960 году в Ливерпуле. Их музыка стала символом эпохи и оказала огромное влияние на мировую культуру. Среди их лучших песен: “Hey Jude”, “Let It Be”, “Yesterday”, “Come Together”, “Here Comes the Sun”, “A Day in the Life”, “Something”, “Eleanor Rigby” и многие другие. Их творчество отличается мелодичностью, глубиной текстов и экспериментами в звуке, что сделало их одной из самых влиятельных групп в истории музыки. Музыка 2024 года слушать онлайн и скачать бесплатно mp3.

  6. Thank you for your sharing. I am worried that I lack creative ideas. It is your article that makes me full of hope. Thank you. But, I have a question, can you help me? https://www.binance.info/es/join?ref=DB40ITMB

  7. Extended Opportunity says:

    Hey Guys,

    Warning: From February 2024, all existing email autoresponders will become obsolete!

    In fact, if you want to send marketing emails, promotional emails, or any other sort of emails starting in February 2024, you’ll need to comply with Gmail’s and Yahoo’s draconic new directives.

    They require regular marketers like you and I to setup complex code on sending domains… and existing autoresponders like Aweber and GetResponse are not helping: they’re requesting you do all the work, and their training is filled with complex instructions and flowcharts…

    How would you like to send unlimited emails at the push of a button all with done-for-you DMARC, DKIM, SPF, custom IPs and dedicated SMTP sending servers?

    What I mean by all of that tech talk above, is that with ProfitMarc, we give you pre-set, pre-configured, DONE-FOR-YOU email sending addresses you can just load up and mail straight away.

    We don’t even have any “setup tutorials” like other autoresponders either, because guess what: we already did all the setup for you!

    All of our built-in sending addresses and servers are already pre-warmed with Gmail and Yahoo and they’re loving us: 99% inbox rate is the average!

    ⇒ Grab your copy here! ⇒ https://ext-opp.com/ProfitMarc

  8. Extended Opportunity says:

    Hey Guys,

    Warning: From February 2024, all existing email autoresponders will become obsolete!

    In fact, if you want to send marketing emails, promotional emails, or any other sort of emails starting in February 2024, you’ll need to comply with Gmail’s and Yahoo’s draconic new directives.

    They require regular marketers like you and I to setup complex code on sending domains… and existing autoresponders like Aweber and GetResponse are not helping: they’re requesting you do all the work, and their training is filled with complex instructions and flowcharts…

    How would you like to send unlimited emails at the push of a button all with done-for-you DMARC, DKIM, SPF, custom IPs and dedicated SMTP sending servers?

    What I mean by all of that tech talk above, is that with ProfitMarc, we give you pre-set, pre-configured, DONE-FOR-YOU email sending addresses you can just load up and mail straight away.

    We don’t even have any “setup tutorials” like other autoresponders either, because guess what: we already did all the setup for you!

    All of our built-in sending addresses and servers are already pre-warmed with Gmail and Yahoo and they’re loving us: 99% inbox rate is the average!

    ⇒ Grab your copy here! ⇒ https://ext-opp.com/ProfitMarc

  9. Extended Opportunity says:

    Hey Guys,

    Warning: From February 2024, all existing email autoresponders will become obsolete!

    In fact, if you want to send marketing emails, promotional emails, or any other sort of emails starting in February 2024, you’ll need to comply with Gmail’s and Yahoo’s draconic new directives.

    They require regular marketers like you and I to setup complex code on sending domains… and existing autoresponders like Aweber and GetResponse are not helping: they’re requesting you do all the work, and their training is filled with complex instructions and flowcharts…

    How would you like to send unlimited emails at the push of a button all with done-for-you DMARC, DKIM, SPF, custom IPs and dedicated SMTP sending servers?

    What I mean by all of that tech talk above, is that with ProfitMarc, we give you pre-set, pre-configured, DONE-FOR-YOU email sending addresses you can just load up and mail straight away.

    We don’t even have any “setup tutorials” like other autoresponders either, because guess what: we already did all the setup for you!

    All of our built-in sending addresses and servers are already pre-warmed with Gmail and Yahoo and they’re loving us: 99% inbox rate is the average!

    ⇒ Grab your copy here! ⇒ https://ext-opp.com/ProfitMarc

  10. Thank you for your sharing. I am worried that I lack creative ideas. It is your article that makes me full of hope. Thank you. But, I have a question, can you help me? https://accounts.binance.com/sv/register-person?ref=FIHEGIZ8

  11. Your article helped me a lot, is there any more related content? Thanks! https://www.binance.info/cs/join?ref=S5H7X3LP

  12. aziz says:

    PLEASE HELP ME

    My name is Aziz Badawi, I’m 27 year old man from Palestine. Our town has recently evacuated due
    to bombardments by Israel, now I am staying at a shelter with my 6 year old daughter Nadia. My wife is
    dead and I’m the only one left to take care of my daughter as we are not allowed to depart to my parents house
    in Nablus, she is sick with a congenital heart defect and I have no way to afford the medicine she needs anymore.
    People here at the shelter are much in the same conditions as ourselves…

    I’m looking for a kind soul who can help us with a donation, any amount will help even 1$ we will
    save money to get her medicine, the doctor at the shelter said if I can’t find a way to get her the
    medication she needs her little heart may give out during the coming weeks.

    If you wish to help me and my daughter please make any amount donation in bitcoin cryptocurrency
    to this bitcoin wallet: bc1qcfh092j2alhswg8jr7fr7ky2sd7qr465zdsrh8

    If you cannot donate please forward this message to your friends, thank you to everyone who’s helping me and my daughter.

  13. Thank you for your sharing. I am worried that I lack creative ideas. It is your article that makes me full of hope. Thank you. But, I have a question, can you help me? https://accounts.binance.com/zh-TC/register?ref=T7KCZASX

  14. Your article helped me a lot, is there any more related content? Thanks! https://www.binance.info/ph/join?ref=V3MG69RO

  15. I don’t think the title of your article matches the content lol. Just kidding, mainly because I had some doubts after reading the article. https://www.binance.com/fr/join?ref=53551167

  16. binance kod says:

    Your article helped me a lot, is there any more related content? Thanks! https://www.binance.info/join?ref=V2H9AFPY

  17. Thanks for sharing. I read many of your blog posts, cool, your blog is very good. https://www.binance.com/de-CH/join?ref=V2H9AFPY

  18. Hdfilmcehennemi – Türkiye’nin en hızlı hd film izleme sitesi. Tek ve gerçek hdfilmcehennemi sitesi. Bob Bloor

  19. 2006 yılının hit aksiyon filmi “CRANK”te, suikastçı Chev Chelios (Jason Statham) damarlarında akan ölümcül zehirle mücadele etmek için 24 saatini dövüşerek, öldürerek ve adrenalin düzeyini üst seviyede tutarak geçirmişti. Şimdi, serinin yüksek oktanlı devam filmi “TETİKÇİ 2: YÜKSEK GERİLİM / CRANK HIGH VOLTAGE”da, geçen sefer hayatta kalmayı başarmış olan Chev yepyeni bir güne uyanmak üzeredir… Owen Chaulklin

  20. Pale Rider, ağır ilerleyişine rağmen, ustalıkla kurgulanmış finaliyle, farklı bir Eastwood westerni.. Tyler Kama

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *